The Heroic Failure Trophy

The Wall Street Journal has a terrific article today about Grey New York, an advertising agency.   The firm's leader, Tor Myhren, has created a quarterly "Heroic Failure" award to encourage innovative risk-taking.   It reminded me of the Build-A-Bear award program that I wrote about several years ago.    Here is an excerpt from what I wrote about the Build-A-Bear "Red Pencil" award program. 


[Build-A-Bear CEO Maxine] Clark has built an incredibly successful company, growing it to over $350 million in sales over the past decade. She has done so by delivering a world-class customer experience in her stores. Clark credits her store associates, who constantly find ways to innovate and improve. How do the associates do it? For starters, they tend not to fear admitting a mistake or surfacing a problem. Clark’s attitude toward mistakes explains her associates’ behavior. She does not punish people for making an error or bringing a problem to light; she encourages it.

Clark credits her first grade teacher, Mrs. Grace, for instilling this attitude toward mistakes in her long ago. As many elementary school teachers do, Mrs. Grace graded papers using a red pencil. However, unlike most of her colleagues, Mrs. Grace gave out a rather unorthodox award at the end of each week. She awarded a red pencil prize to the student who had made the most mistakes! Why? Mrs. Grace wanted her students engaged in the class discussion, trying to answer every question - no matter how challenging. As Clark writes, "She didn't want the fear of being wrong to keep us from taking chances. Her only rule was that we couldn't be rewarded for making the same mistake twice."  

Clark has applied her first grade teacher's approach at Build-a-Bear by creating a Red Pencil Award. She gives this prize to people who have made a mistake, but who have discovered a better way of doing business as a result of reflecting upon and learning from that mistake. Clark has it right when she says that managers should encourage their people to "experiment freely, and view every so-called mistake as one step closer to getting things just right." Of course, her first grade teacher had it right as well when she stressed that people would be held accountable if they made the same mistake repeatedly. Failing to learn constitutes the bad behavior that managers should deem unacceptable. Clark makes that point clear to her associates.

Excerpt from Michael A. Roberto, Know What You Don't Know, Wharton School Publishing, 2009.  

Quotes are from Maxine Clark's book, The bear necessities of business: Building acompany with heart.  John Wiley and Sons.  2006.